October 21, 2024 by emilysmaids
The in-office interview is a crucial stage in the hiring process, offering an opportunity to get a deeper understanding of your potential team member. This guide will help you navigate the interview process effectively, ensuring you select the best candidate for the role.
Preparing for the Interview
Before diving into the interview itself, prepare the following forms and have them ready:
- Phone Interview & Evaluation Form (from the phone interview)
- Team Member Job Description Form
- Employment Application Form
- Personal Evaluation Form
- Authorization for Release of Information Form
- Company marketing materials (for the candidate to take home)
These documents will help structure the conversation and ensure you cover all necessary details.
Starting the Interview: First Impressions Matter
When the candidate arrives, it’s essential to make them feel welcome. A friendly greeting sets the tone for the rest of the interview. Offer them something to drink—small gestures like this can help ease any nerves and make the candidate feel comfortable from the get-go.
But there’s one rule that cannot be overlooked: punctuality. If the candidate arrives 15 minutes late (or more) without prior notice, it’s best to end the process there. Punctuality is an important quality, and not respecting the agreed-upon time can be a red flag.
Explaining the Job Clearly
Once the candidate is settled, it’s time to explain the position in detail. Hand them a copy of the Team Member Job Description and ensure they fully understand the role’s expectations, challenges, and responsibilities.
This is also a great time to establish an open and honest dialogue. Be transparent about the role and your company, and encourage the candidate to be truthful about their experiences. A simple yet effective statement you can make is:
“I’m going to be very open and honest with you about this job and our company, and I expect the same from you. It doesn’t matter if you’ve ever resigned, been fired, or had difficulty with a former boss—just let me know. We can take that into consideration. But if you hide something and we find out later during background checks, I won’t be able to hire you. Do you understand?”
This helps foster a sense of trust and encourages the candidate to be upfront about their work history.
Reviewing the Application Together
Next, have the candidate fill out the Employment Application Form and the Authorization for Release of Information Form. Be nearby to assist if they have any questions.
Once they’ve completed the forms, walk through the Employment Application Form together. This part of the interview allows you to explore the candidate’s background while using the evaluation symbols (+, , –, X) from the phone interview to rate their responses.
Sitting across a desk can create a barrier, so try to sit next to the candidate instead. This setup makes the conversation feel more natural and relaxed, allowing the candidate to open up more freely. As you discuss each section of their application, ask follow-up questions to clarify any details and assign ratings based on their answers.
Scoring:
- Perfect Candidate: 150 Points
- Good Candidate: 105 Points
- Minimal Candidate: 60 Points (with no “X”)
If the candidate scores below 60, it’s time to end the interview politely, explaining that they may not be the best fit for the role.
Personal Interview: A More Relaxed Conversation
If the candidate scores above 60, it’s time to move on to the personal interview, which should feel more like a casual, open conversation. Your goal is to learn more about the candidate’s values, work style, and how they might fit within your company culture.
Start by putting down your pen and any paperwork. Lean back in your chair, lower your voice a bit, and make the candidate feel at ease. This encourages them to speak freely and honestly, giving you valuable insights into how they think and work.
Behavioral-Based Questions: Getting to Know the Candidate
Here are three key questions to ask during the personal interview:
1. Work Values
“I see on your application that you’ve had a couple of jobs like [insert previous job]. I’ve had a few different roles myself, and what I’ve found is that certain things are always important to me in a job. How about you? What’s been really important to you in the jobs you’ve had?”
This question helps you understand what the candidate values in their work. Are they motivated by independence, recognition, or perhaps job security? These insights will help you assess if they will be a good fit for your company.
2. Handling Stress
“Every job has its frustrations. I know I’ve had some tough days. How about you? Can you tell me about a time you were really upset at work and how you handled it?”
This question helps gauge the candidate’s ability to cope with stress. Look for responses that show they can handle frustration in a mature and professional way. If their answers involve extreme reactions, like quitting on the spot, that might be a red flag.
3. Teamwork
“I’m sure you’ve worked in teams before. For me, working in a group has its ups and downs. What’s been your experience? What did you like, and what didn’t you like about working with others?”
Teamwork is crucial for most roles, and this question helps you determine how well the candidate works with others. Do they enjoy collaboration, or do they prefer working independently? This is important information for making your decision.
Scoring the Personal Interview
After asking these questions, complete your evaluation using the same symbols (+, , –, X).
- Perfect Candidate: 30 Points
- Good Candidate: 21 Points
- Minimal Candidate: 12 Points
If their score is lower than 12, it may be best to end the interview politely.
Closing the Interview
As you wrap up the conversation, give the candidate a chance to ask any questions they may have about the role. If they seem like a strong fit, confirm their interest in the position and explain the next steps, such as reference and background checks.
Don’t forget to thank the candidate for their time, provide them with company materials like brochures or business cards, and make sure they leave with a positive impression of your company—even if you decide not to move forward with their application.
Final Thoughts
The in-office interview is your opportunity to dive deeper into a candidate’s work style, values, and personality. By creating a welcoming environment, asking thoughtful questions, and taking the time to evaluate their responses, you’ll have a much better chance of finding the right person for the job.
Step 4 of Our Hiring Process: Background Investigation